This used to be a blog for an English independent scholar of fantasy fiction - but then "Doctor Who" stole my brain, my heart, my soul and my life - so these days it's more a Blog about my on-going utter obsession with "Doctor Who" - with occasional non-DW book reviews and discussions.
Friday, June 22, 2007
Carnegie of Carnegies
It's been announced that Philip Pullman's Northern Lights has won the Carnegie of Carnegies (about which I posted in April). I confess, I voted for Alan Garner's The Owl Service, simply because it had such a huge impact on me as a child reader.
(I confess that I heard this news late yesterday but I was trying to work on both my current fiction tales (simultaneously more or less), so I didn't post it !)
I'd go for Rosemary Sutcliff. (e?)
ReplyDeleteMind you, in my opinion, this is Pullman's masterpiece. His other books that I've read come nowhwere near it.
It's a very good book, but it simply didn't have the impact on me that The Owl Service had...
ReplyDelete